Which router is better? Netgear or Linksys?

Life, Lies, Sex, Humor, Politics of a Malaysian blogger

The Obnoxious 5xmom

August 14th, 2006 at 1:20 am

Which router is better? Netgear or Linksys?

My current [tag]Netgear[/tag][tag] router[/tag] is the  801.11b (11Mps) type which is not compatible with my laptop.  My Acer can’t get the wireless signal and right now, I am using cable.

It is several years old and we are thinking of getting the later version – 801.11g type  , 54 Mps which is only about RM175.  Previously, we had [tag]Linksys[/tag] but for some weird reasons, it keeps giving problems.  We bought the Netgear while the Linksys was at the repair shop (while under warranty) and later gave away the Linksys (a new unit) to someone.

I read that the 54Mps is five times faster than the 11Mps which I think is bullshit because [tag]Telekom[/tag][tag] streamyx [/tag]is dead slow so nothing can go faster anyway. Ibadat apek mati pucuk, kena kopi tongkat ali pun tak ada reaksi.   Right or not?  We subscribe  to the RM88 [tag]broadband[/tag] package.
So, any brand recommendation?  The Linksys is more expensive than Netgear by about RM60 but it has some added features like a buffer or something (regulating the signal like that).  However, I doubt we want another Linksys due to the past problems.  And over here, where I am, the shops stock mostly Netgear, Linksys and Aztec (I think?) only.
Faster-faster, tell me which brand to buy ‘cos I am tired of having a laptop that is tied to a cable, unless I picked up some neighbour’s wi-fi signal. ;)    We have two PCs and two laptops at home in a 800 sq ft area.  Me wanna secretly surft p0rn from the toilet also cannot.  Hahaha.

Related posts:

  1. Router questions – Tolong….
  2. Neighbour’s broadband, 3-column WP and Tiga
  3. P1 Wimax can go fly kite with their sky high promises
  4. Important message brought to you jointly by Rojakz and 5xmom
  5. Three DELL stolen plus wedding ring
  6. 3 hours at PIKOM & my laptop is here!
  7. Patah kaki dan tangan

-
19
  • Lilian
    1:24 am on August 14th, 2006 1

    BTW, I had done what was suggested in my previous related post. Another thing is the line keep getting cut off and we have to on/off the router very often. We have set the number of computers to access too.

  • @ZR¦N
    4:02 am on August 14th, 2006 2

    I have a Netgear and Linksys and now a Thomson router, with pros & cons of each.

    What you are having problem is typical of WiFi in a buildup area…
    My Guide to Malaysian Problematic WiFi Broadband

    I create this for you…
    But in a nutshell, NO NEED TO GET NEW ONE. Unless you fried your old router big time!

  • Wuching
    8:49 am on August 14th, 2006 3

    soli lar, i’ve only come across netgear so cannot give unbiased opinion!

  • Keen
    9:21 am on August 14th, 2006 4

    It should be noted that when its talking about 11Mbps and 54Mbps it is not talking about Streamyx’s speed. The WLAN’s speed and your broadband speed are two different things altogether. Thus the speed on the routers are in reference to the speed of data transfer between your computers and the router, while the speed of Streamyx is from ther interweb to your modem.

  • Keen
    9:26 am on August 14th, 2006 5

    Also there really shouldn’t be an issue over what router to buy unless we are looking at specific models.

    Ooh I can’t vouch for the model you linked to though. My sister has it, but is having problems with her wireless network like being only able to connect to the internet in the evening. But that may be due to her ISP than the router itself, which does work in the sense that she is always connected to it wirelessly.

  • QuaVadis
    9:47 am on August 14th, 2006 6

    Not computer savvy enough..as long as the system jalan..no complaints hahaha

  • wingz
    9:55 am on August 14th, 2006 7

    use old RJ45 cables like me la gerenti no problem wan!

  • moo_t
    10:58 am on August 14th, 2006 8

    Linksys is under Cisco now, so everything under Cisco is expensive. Since you use notebook, just bring it over to the shop and configure there. Save all the hassle reading the manual.

  • Prometeuz
    11:31 am on August 14th, 2006 9

    I am using both Netgear and Dlink. But I onli use the wire ports….never like wireless.

  • gbyeow
    12:34 pm on August 14th, 2006 10

    I prefer Linksys. Streamyx screwing up again. They open too mnay ports without upgrading the backbone. That means 1mbps disconnections.

  • frostier
    2:38 pm on August 14th, 2006 11

    I kenot recommend to you since I got no commission for the router u going to buy.

    But then hor, i was thinking that Linksys mia wireless router got sapport a/b/g one. You think it’s good ah? You go try la. I think must be good than other brand one.

    If u dun belief me, can also try 3com mia also. That 1 i tak tau apa model la. but if those mentioned ada a/b/g can consider la

  • CLF
    2:39 pm on August 14th, 2006 12

    I just bought NetGear, the same u posted the link. So far, so good, I get it at RM 145 at PCfair. I think it’s good tho.

  • frostier
    2:40 pm on August 14th, 2006 13

    one more thing is that if there’s g and ur card can support g, go for it.
    :P

  • menj
    2:55 pm on August 14th, 2006 14

    Neither. Get D-Link. The price is lower and quality is not compromised either. I am using a D-Link ADSL Wireless DSL-G604T

    - MENJ

  • MumOf2
    3:54 pm on August 14th, 2006 15

    So, made up yr mind Lillian? Honestly, nowadays Streamyx super slow la. Takes ages to download a file and half d time I get disconnected!

  • Keen
    4:23 pm on August 14th, 2006 16

    The router MENJ recommended I wholly support. I use it too and hasn’t failed me.

  • romantic
    8:30 pm on August 14th, 2006 17

    I use D-Link too ..very good.

  • iamyuanwu
    1:11 am on August 15th, 2006 18

    Hey, I looking around for a good wireless router too. I’m contemplating between Linksys and Netgear.

    Then a friend of mine recommended Belkin. Not cheap (I’ve checked the price, +-RM220), but according to him works like a wonder.

    Oh, do let us know when you have bought a new router, tell us how well it works. Hehe.

  • surfnux
    1:06 pm on August 15th, 2006 19

    Your Acer is centrino duo?

    Actually, no router is perfect. All are mostly the same. Some products their life also depends, some who are lucky, can have the router working for more than 5 years and gone. Some even 1 year started to have problems. hehee

    Belkin has lifetime warranty, and I believe some other like Linksys and Dlink are starting to give life time warranty for some of their routers.

    54mbps, is fine enough. If you no enough, get Wireless N (108 mbps). :p But your wireless adapter must support also lor. Else, no point getting high speed without the support. heehh Just some two cents here. Tired of replying to support cases on routers. :p

 

RSS feed for comments on this post | TrackBack URI